Your Source for Fresh Amish Cheese & Butter

These wonderful Amish cheeses come from one of the few remaining farmer-owned Amish co-ops, which includes approximately 120 members, nearly all of whom are Amish. Each small farm is a labor of love, consisting of no more than 20 cows. Hand-milking is the norm, and the fresh milk is delivered to the USDA-approved Amish-run cheese plant in traditional 10-gallon milk cans. These cows are not treated with BST growth hormones, are not fed GMO feed, and are kept in good health in comfortable environments. From early spring to late fall, the cows are out on pasture, enjoying the luscious grass and sunshine.

Certified non-GMO, Kosher and Halal vegetable rennet is used in these cheeses, rather than animal rennet. The result of all this is an exceptional local cheese, bursting with wholesome flavor, and free of artificial hormones or steroids.


Products 1-12 of 22
Show
Asiago asiago, amish asiago, amish asiago cheese, asiago cheese, aged cheese, amish aged cheese, parmasian, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $4.00
(5)
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 124 -

Asiago is an aged cow's milk cheese that has a crumbly texture with a flavor reminiscent of Parmesan. This wonderful cheese is often grated in salads, soups, pastas, and sauces. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes

Brick Brick, amish brick, amish brick cheese, brick cheese, brick of cheese, creamy cheese, creamy amish cheese, butter cheese, amish butter cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.50
(6)
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 123 -

Brick Cheese is a full milk brick with a creamy texture and buttery flavor. Perfect shredded on pizza or toasted on Italian bread. This creamy cheese was originally shaped and pressed with bricks, hence the name. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Enzymes, Salt<

Buffalo Jack spicy cheese, hot cheese, buffalo jack, amish buffalo jack, amish jack, amish jack cheese, jack cheese, amish buffalo jack cheese, buffalo cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.80
(1)
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 116 -

Try this exciting flavored Monterey Jack cheese! This cheese is full of buffalo wing flavor, and is hot and spicy. Great on a burger or just for snacking. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Enzymes, Salt, Buffalo Wing Sauce

CoJack Marble cojack marble, colbyjack marble cheese, about colby jack cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.50
(6)
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 106 -

Colby Jack Cheese is the delightful result of wedding Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses. The combination creates a gentle, savory flavor, while the mixing of the yellow and white colors gives it a visual appeal unlike any other specialty cheese. Delicious on sandwiches, apples and crackers, or just slice after delicious slice. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto (color).

Colby Longhorn colby longhorn, colby longhorn cheese, longhorn cheese, amish longhorn cheese, amish colby longhorn, cheddar, amish cheddar, curd cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.50
(1)
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 125 -

Similar in flavor to Cheddar, Colby Cheese is a stirred-curd cheese made with pasteurized milk, like Monterey Jack. Colby cheese has a slightly higher moisture content than cheddar, giving it a softer texture and a mellow, buttery flavor. This cheese comes in the traditional longhorn cylinder shape. Try it in a sandwich or served as an appetizer with your favorite crackers or bread. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto (color). ...

Cracker Pack 8oz Cheddar, cheddar, colby jack, colby, marble, marble cheese, monterey jack, monterey jack cheese, jack cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.70
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 115 -

This Cracker Pack includes four cheeses: Cheddar, Colby, Marble, and Monterey Jack. Makes a great gift. Just slice it, and you have four cracker-size pieces ready to serve! Crackers NOT included. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Enzymes, Salt, Annato (color).

Farmers farmers cheese, about farmers cheese, what is farmers cheese, farmers, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.50
(6)
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 105 -

Farmers Cheese is delightfully basic and uncomplicated. It is a fresh, mild cheese with a slightly tangy taste, and a texture that is moist, yet dry enough to be sliced. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes

Fiesta Cheddar fiesta cheddar, cheddar, fiesta cheese, spicy cheese, spicy cheddar, jalepenio cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.80
(1)
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 117 -

Fiesta Cheddar cheese is one hot cheddar! This is a mild colored cheddar infused with jalapeño peppers. This is a bit hotter than the pepper jack, and the texture is a bit creamier. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Enzymes, Salt, Annato (color), Jalapeño Peppers. ...

Fresh Cheese Curds fresh cheese curds, fresh cheese, cheese curds, curds, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.75
(12)
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 40 -

Cheese Curds are squeaky fresh, delectable cheddar cheese in its natural, random shape and form before being processed into blocks of cheddar. Their flavor is mild with about the same firmness as cheese, but they have a slight rubbery texture. They are somewhat salty. Fresh curds squeak against the teeth when bitten into, a defining characteristic. Cheese curds are sometimes referred to as "squeaky cheese."Our curds always receive rave reviews (read them yourself on the Review tab). We know...

Habanero habanero, habanero cheese, amish habanera cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.50
(4)
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 110 -

Habanero Hot Cheese is a dramatic flavor blending of savory mellow monterey jack with the spice of Habanero creating a fiery combination. A semi-firm, creamy, and very spicy cheese with Habanero pepper pieces throughout. Hot stuff! Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes, Habanero Peppers

Horseradish Cheese horseradish cheese, amish horseradish cheese, about horseradish cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.80
(3)
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 111 -

Horseradish Cheese is rich in flavor, with a subtle nuance of horseradish. This gourmet Monterey Jack cheese is delightful on its own, or perfect for cooking, snacking, and positively excellent on sandwiches. It is fabulous in a holiday cheese ball! Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes, Horseradish

Marble Pepper Jack marble pepper jack, pepper jack, marble pepper jack cheese, jack cheese, amish pepper jack, amish marble cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
Price: $3.50
Availability: In Stock
Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op Item #: 121 -

Marble Pepper Jack Cheese blends Monterey Jack with Colby and adds the spicy "zing" of jalapeño peppers to create a flavor that both comforts and invigorates. Add Marble Pepper Jack cheese to Southwestern recipes or simply enjoy it cubed with crackers as a snack. Use it in macaroni and cheese, or on grilled cheese sandwiches to give them a kick! Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Enzymes, Salt, Jalapeño Peppers, Annatto (color)